네티즌 200자평 (가장 최근 것이 위에) | |
de***: 뵘등의 기존 해석에서는 1악장이 대하의 흐름같았다면 가디너는 관이 현,타악기와 동등한 자격으로 평행을 그리며 울부짖는 음향은 사자의 포효같았고 서두른다는 느낌이 들정도로 숨가쁘게 내달린다. 2악장부터는 아랫분 말씀대로 미소짓는 브람스를 만날 수 있었는데 3악장의 목관이 상쾌해서 좋았고 4악장은 더 없이 밝지만 가볍지 않다. 텁텁한 뒷맛이 없는 브람스이고 비교적 해석 차가 적은 1번의 음반중 훌륭한 대안이다. 4명 (10명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 10/07/25 03:55
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| be***: 마침내 브람스 1번의 레퍼런스를 찾았다. 바흐와 베토벤을 추앙했지만 브람스의 시선은 언제나 우리를 향하고 있었다. 가디너가 켜켜이 썋여있던 구태의 먼지를 털어내자 그는 고집스레 오그라붙었던 입가에 천진한 미소를 지어보였다. 3명 (18명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 08/12/17 12:46
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| si***: 가디너가 말하고자 했던 바가 뭔지 모르겠다. 평이한 연주. 적당한 감동...다음 곡에 대한 기대감을 접었다. 6명 (15명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 08/11/18 23:23
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| pr***: 가디너...제시부반복 포함해서 44분여의 짧은 시간에 달리고 있습니다. 전반적으로 중후함보다는 날렵함으로 승부하려는 경향이 있습니다. 기대했던 방향의 해석이지만 그다지 매력적이지는 않습니다. 베토벤 교향곡 때 보여주었던, 날렵하면서도 구조미가 드러나고 맺을때 맺어주는, 소위 edge 가 브람스에서는 부족하다는 느낌을 받았습니다. 호불호가 엇갈릴 거 같습니다만 제 취향은 아니었습니다. 9명 (15명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 08/10/02 17:36
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
|
|
네티즌 리뷰 | | 리뷰는 동호회 게시판으로 링크됩니다.
BRAHMS: Symphony No. 1 in C minor op. 68 | 등록된 음반: 367종 |
브람스: 교향곡 1번 C단조 op. 68 (전곡녹음 - 녹음연도순) | 1927/04/25-27 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1928/02 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1928/03/20 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1936/01/15 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1937/05/03 | Bruno Walter |
| 1937/12/25 | Arturo Toscanini
|
| 1938/09/19-20 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1939/02/18 | Felix Weingartner |
| 1940/05/06 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1940/10/13 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1940/12 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1941/03/10 | Arturo Toscanini [1] |
| 1941/07/03,04 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1941/07/08 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1943/01/17 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1943/04/13 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1943/09/16-17 | Herbert von Karajan [2] |
| 1943/9 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1944/11/18,19 | Karl Bohm |
| 1945/01/08 | Artur Rodzinski |
| 1945/02/17 | Serge Koussevitzky |
| 1946/08/01 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1947/08/27 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1947/09/20 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1947/11/17-20 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1949 | Yevgeny Mravinsky |
| 1949/12/10 | Hermann Abendroth [1] |
| 1950/07/13 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1950/10/08-19 | Karl Bohm |
| 1950/11/05 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1951 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1951 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1951/04/15 | Karl Bohm |
| 1951/09 | Eduard van Beinum [1] |
| 1951/10/25 | Eduard Van Beinum |
| 1951/10/27 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [8] |
| 1951/11/03 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1951/11/03 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1951/11/06 | Arturo Toscanini [2] |
| 1952/01/27 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1952/02/10 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [8] |
| 1952/03/07 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1952/03/13 | Clemens Krauss |
| 1952/04/21 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1952/05/14 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1952/09/29 | Arturo Toscanini [6] |
| 1952/10 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1952/10/30 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1952/12/06 | Guido Cantelli |
| 1952/5 & 7 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1953/05/11 | Guido Cantelli |
| 1953/05/18 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1953/05/21-22 | Guido Cantelli [8] |
| 1953/12 | Eugen Jochum [3] |
| 1953/12/04 | Willem van Otterloo |
| 1953/12/28 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1953/12/30 | Bruno Walter [1] |
| 1954/03/20 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1954/03/27 | Guido Cantelli |
| 1954/08/24 | Sir John Barbirolli |
| 1954/09/17 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1954/11/06 | Karl Bohm |
| 1955/02/27 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1955/05/15 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1955/09/19 | Hans Rosbaud |
| 1955/10/17 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1956/01/16 | Hermann Abendroth [2] |
| 1956/02/08 | Ferenc Fricsay [1] |
| 1956/04/17 | William Steinberg |
| 1956/10 | Josef Krips [1] |
| 1956/10/29, 31 & 1957/03/28 | Otto Klemperer [4] |
| 1956/11/03-04 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1956/11/19 | Charles Munch |
| 1956/12/06 | Sir Georg Solti |
| 1956/12/19-21 | Igor Markevitch [1] |
| 1957 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1957/03/01-02 | George Szell |
| 1957/12/12 or 19 | Yascha Horenstein |
| 1958 | Jascha Horenstein [1] |
| 1958 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1958/02/02~03 | Ferenc Fricsay |
| 1958/05/13 | Leopold Stokowski [1] |
| 1958/05/25 | Sir John Barbirolli |
| 1958/09/29 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1958/10/06-07 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1958/10/06-07 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1958/9/25 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1959 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1959/01/02, 03 & 05 | Rudolf Kempe [1] |
| 1959/02/08 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1959/03/23, 26 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1959/06/16-18 | Antal Dorati |
| 1959/09/17 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1959/10 | Karl Bohm [33] |
| 1959/10/12 | Igor Markevitch |
| 1959/10/27 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1959/11/25 | Bruno Walter [10] |
| 1960/02/23 | Leopold Stokowski [1] |
| 1960/02/25 | Ferdinand Leitner |
| 1960/05/02 | Leonard Bernstein [3] |
| 1960/06/27, 07/04 | Hans Rosbaud |
| 1961 | Witold Rowicki |
| 1961/01/16-17 | Carlo Maria Giulini [1] |
| 1961/09/28-29 | Herbert Kegel |
| 1961/10/31 | Charles Munch [1] |
| 1961/11 | William Steinberg |
| 1962/01 | Karel Ancerl |
| 1962/01/29,30 | Jascha Horenstein |
| 1962/06/07 | Karel Ancerl |
| 1962/06/12, 13 | Franz Konwitschny |
| 1962/08/29 | George Szell |
| 1962/09/06 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1962/12 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1962/12/20 | Charles Munch |
| 1963/02 | Ernest Ansermet |
| 1963/04/05 | Karl Böhm |
| 1963/10/11-12 | Herbert von Karajan [7] |
| 1963/11/20 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1963/11/24 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1963/9/18 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1964/09/15 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1965 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1966/02/26 | János Ferencsik |
| 1966/04/22 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1966/06/26 | Karel Ancerl |
| 1966/10/07 | George Szell [3] |
| 1966/10/08 | George Szell |
| 1966/10/20 | Charles Munch |
| 1967/01/28 | Lovro von Matacic |
| 1967/03/31 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1967/06/05 | Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt |
| 1967/12/4~8 | Sir John Barbirolli |
| 1968/01/08,12 | Charles Munch [9] |
| 1968/05/14 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1968/05/19 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1969/10/02 | Karl Bohm [2] |
| 1970/09/30 | Jean Martinon |
| 1970s | Hans Swarowsky |
| 1971 | Sir Adrian Boult |
| 1971/09/04 | Sir Georg Solti |
| 1971/11/03-06 | Kurt Sanderling [1] |
| 1972/03 | Claudio Abbado |
| 1972/06/15 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1972/12 | Bernard Haitink [1] |
| 1973 | Istvan Kertesz [1] |
| 1973/01, 02, 05 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1973/03/27 | Herbert Kegel [1] |
| 1973/06/23 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1973/08/01-03 | Leonard Bernstein |
| 1973/10/18 | Kurt Sanderling |
| 1974/07 | James Loughran |
| 1975/01 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1975/03/17 | Karl Bohm [1] |
| 1975/05 | Karl Bohm [7] |
| 1975/07/23 | James Levine |
| 1975/08 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1975/3/22 | Karl Bohm |
| 1976 | Eugen Jochum [3] |
| 1976/04/09 | Peter Maag |
| 1976/05/17-24 | Maurice de Abravanel [1] |
| 1976/09/21 | Karl Bohm |
| 1976/09/24 | Klaus Tennstedt |
| 1976/10 | Kurt Masur [1] |
| 1976/10/21 | Sergiu Celibidache [1] |
| 1976/2/10,11,17 | Zubin Mehta |
| 1976/8/17 | Sir Adrian Boult |
| 1976ⓟ | Kirill Kondrashin |
| 1977/03/28, 04/02 | Seiji Ozawa [2] |
| 1977/10-1978/02 | Herbert von Karajan [7] |
| 1978 | Gunther Herbig [1] |
| 1979/01/26 | Carlo Maria Giulini [1] |
| 1979/06 | Georg Solti |
| 1980/02/29 | Kirill Kondrashin |
| 1980/05/08-1982/05/14 | Eugen Jochum [1] |
| 1980/06/09~18 | Heinz Rögner |
| 1981 | Carlos Paita |
| 1981/06/07 & 08 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1981/10 | Leonard Bernstein [7] |
| 1981/11 | Carlo Maria Giulini [7] |
| 1982 | Evgeny Svetlanov [2] |
| 1982/05/26-07/17 | Gunter Wand [2] |
| 1982/09/20 | Zibin Metha |
| 1982/10/26-29 & 1982/12/16-17 | Gunter Wand |
| 1983/04/26-29 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1983/09/21-22 | Klaus Tennstedt [2] |
| 1983/12/08 | Gunter Wand |
| 1984/03/24 | Lovro von Matacic |
| 1984/09/07 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1985/03/03 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1986 | Otmar Suitner |
| 1986/10 | Christoph von Dohnanyi |
| 1987/01 | Herbert von Karajan [12] |
| 1987/01/21 | Sergiu Celibidache [3] |
| 1987/01/23~29 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1987/05 | Riccardo Chailly [1] |
| 1987/05/16 | Neeme Jarvi |
| 1987/09/06,07 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 1987/09/07,08 | Jirl Belohlavek |
| 1987/09/07~08 | Jiří Bělohlávek |
| 1988/04 | Andrew Litton |
| 1988/04/24 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1988/05/05 | Herbert von Karajan [2] |
| 1988/06/13 | Otmar Suitner [3] |
| 1988/10/06 | Herbert von Karajan [8] |
| 1988/12/18 | Ferdinand Leitner |
| 1989/01/19-21 | Gunter Wand |
| 1989/03/28 | Kazuo Yamada [1] |
| 1989/04/27-/05/05 | Alexander Rahbari |
| 1989/09 | Riccardo Muti [5] |
| 1989/10/02~05 | Colin Davis |
| 1989/10/08 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1990 | Kurt Sanderling [1] |
| 1990 | Francesco D'Avalos |
| 1990/02/05 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1990/02/07 | Kurt Sanderling |
| 1990/02/14 | Gunter Wand [1] |
| 1990/05/06 | Klaus Tennstedt |
| 1990/08 | Seiji Ozawa [1] |
| 1990/09 | Claudio Abbado [10] |
| 1990/09 | Roger Norrington [1] |
| 1991 | Christoph Eschenbach |
| 1991 | Kurt Masur |
| 1991/01/21 | Heinz Wallberg |
| 1991/04 | Carlo Maria Giulini [6] |
| 1991/04 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1991/04/25-26 | Sir Colin Davis |
| 1991/06/07 | Herbert Blomstedt |
| 1991/09/01 | Günter Neuhold |
| 1991/11/24 | Vladimir Ashkenazy |
| 1992/02 | Gunther Herbig |
| 1992/10/02 | Emmanuel Krivine |
| 1992/10/04-27 | Zubin Mehta |
| 1992/10/14 | Klaus Tennstedt [1] |
| 1992/10/26~31 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 1992/12/10,11 | Gerd Albrecht |
| 1992/12/10-11 | Gerd Albrecht |
| 1992/6 | TOVE LONSKOV(piano)
RODOLFO |
| 1993 | Marek Janowski |
| 1993/05/13,14 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 1993/08 | James Levine [1] |
| 1994/02/15 | Gunter Wand |
| 1994/04 | Bernard Haitink |
| 1994/05/01-04 | Kurt Masur [1] |
| 1994/11/09 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1995/05/17 | Michael Gielen |
| 1995/10/23 | Peter Maag |
| 1995/12/22~23 | Gunther Schuller |
| 1996/03/24 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt |
| 1996/04/06 | Takashi Asahina [1] |
| 1996/04/15-20 | Silke-Thora Matthies
Christian [1] |
| 1996/04/21-23 | Gunter Wand |
| 1996/04/24-27 | Cristian Mandeal |
| 1996/09/01-10 | Thomas Sanderling |
| 1996/10 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt [8] |
| 1997 | Neville Marriner |
| 1997 | Horst Stein |
| 1997/01/06-30 | Sir Charles Mackerras |
| 1997/02/19,21,23 | Gunter Wand [2] |
| 1997/08/24 | Gunter Wand |
| 1997/12/28~29 | Vladimir Ashkenazy |
| 1998/01/23 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1998/03/01 | Myung-Whun Chung |
| 1998/05/04 | Tamas Vasary |
| 1998/05/06~08 | Eliahu Inbal |
| 1999/10/21,22 | Mariss Jansons |
| 1999/10/28,29; 2003/09/2,3 | James Levine |
| 2000/05/11-14 | Paavo Berglund |
| 2000/09/11 | Takashi Asahina |
| 2000/12/08 | Georges Pretre [1] |
| 2001/03/14 | Gerd Albrecht |
| 2002 ⓟ | Erich Bergel |
| 2002/08/19-24 | Semyon Bychkov |
| 2002/09/29 | Bernard Haitink |
| 2002/09/29-30 | Bernard Haitink |
| 2002/6-8/ | Jaap van Zweden [1] |
| 2003/05 | Bernard Haitink [1] |
| 2003/06/22 | Gary Bertini |
| 2003/10/05 | Christian Arming |
| 2004/01/18, 19 | Marin Alsop |
| 2005/02/21~24 | Martin Sieghart |
| 2005/03/19 | Hiroyuki Iwaki |
| 2005/06 | Christian Thielemann [8] |
| 2005/06/06~08, 2006/05/23~26 | Owain Arwel Hughes |
| 2005/07/04-06 | Roger Norrington [1] |
| 2005/09/02 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2005/09/24 | Yukio Kitahara |
| 2005/10/26~27 | Zdenek Macal |
| 2005/11/10 | Ilan Volkov |
| 2006/12/13~14 | Marcus Bosch |
| 2007/02/26-03/01 | Gustav Kuhn |
| 2007/03 | Marek Janowski |
| 2007/03/11-12 | Simone Young |
| 2007/04/01 | Hun-Joung Lim |
| 2007/09/29 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 2007/1/9 | Myung-Whun Chung [2] |
| 2007/10-11 | John Eliot Gardiner [4] |
| 2007/10/30-31 | Mariss Jansons [2] |
| 2007/11/10 | Hisayoshi Inoue |
| 2008/05/25 | Vladimir Jurowski |
| 2008/07/16~17 | Jonathan Pasternack |
| 2008/09/26 | Daniel Raiskin |
| 2008/10/29~11/14 | Sir Simon Rattle [1] |
| 2008/11/01 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2009 | Thomas Dausgaard |
| 2009-2010 | Andrew Manze |
| 2009/01 | Iván Fischer [1] |
| 2009/01/06 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2009/02/07 | Kazuyoshi Akiyama |
| 2009/04/20~21 | Taijiro Iimori |
| 2009/05/14 | Christoph von Dohnanyi |
| 2009/06/14 | Alexander Lazarev |
| 2009/09/23-24 | Suh Hyunsuk |
| 2009/10/13, 14, 16 | Zubin Mehta |
| 2009~2010 | Andrew Manze |
| 2010/02/16 | Joe Hisaishi |
| 2010/02/25-27 | Lothar Zagrosek |
| 2010/04 | David Zinman |
| 2010/04/27 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2010/04/30~05/01 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2010/07/02 | Eiji Oue |
| 2010/10/16 | Takeharu Nobuhara |
| 2010/11/20 | Eliahu Inbal |
| 2010/12/14 | Seiji Ozawa [1] |
| 2011/02 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski [1] |
| 2011/03 | Thomas Dausgaard |
| 2011/03/27 | Jun Markl |
| 2012 | Zubin Mehta |
| 2012/08/04-05 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2012/10 | Riccardo Chailly [1] |
| 2012/10 | Christian Thielemann |
| 2012/10, 12 | Valery Gergiev |
| 2012/10/22 | Christian Thielemann [2] |
| 2013/01/23~27 | Jukka-Pekka Saraste |
| 2013/05/10 | Jaap van Zweden |
| 2014/04/17~19 | Norichika Iimori |
| 2014/04/22~23 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 2014/09/07 | Franz Welser-Most |
| 2014/09/18 | Sir Simon Rattle [1] |
| 2014/10/23-24 & 27 | Andres Orozco-Estrada |
| 2016/01 | Mario Venzago |
| 2016/03/21-23, 25 | Paavo Jarvi |
| 2016/05/22 | Thomas Hengelbrock |
| 2016/11 | Andris Nelsons [1] |
| 2017/03/10-11 | Radomil Eliska |
| 2017/05/15-29 | Robin Ticciati |
| 2017/09/20 | Kalman Berkes |
| 2017/10 | Daniel Barenboim [2] |
| 2018/03/10 | Toshiyuki Kamioka |
| 2018/04/04 | Paavo Jarvi |
| 2018/10/02-05 | Edward Gardner |
| 2019/03/18-22 | Giancarlo Guerrero |
| 2019/05/11 | Tadaaki Otaka |
| 2019/09 | Herbert Blomstedt [2] |
| 2019/09/25-26 | Philippe Jordan |
| 2019/11/28-30 | Christoph Eschenbach |
| 2020/02/12-13 | Joe Hisaishi |
| 2021/01/26~29, 02/02~05 | Nicholas Milton |
| 2021/05/10-18, 07/03-06, 09/23-25 & 2022/02/12-14 | Adam Fischer |
| 2022/04/29 | Kenshiro Sakairi |
| 2022/05/05 | Michiyoshi Inoue |
| 2022/06/23-25 | Michael Sanderling |
| 2023/05/10-11 | Joe Hisaishi |
|
재킷 사진은 외부 링크된 것이라 늦게 뜨거나 보이지 않을 수도 있습니다.
|