네티즌 200자평 (가장 최근 것이 위에) | |
op***: 요스 판 이머젤의 아기자기하면서도 투명하고 유연한 9번과는 대척점에 서 있다. 말랑말랑하고 깨알같지는 않지만, 묵직하고 폭발적이면서도 속이 뻥 뚫리는 시원함이 일품이다. 이로서 9번의 고증연주는 슈페링-이머젤-가디너의 3파전으로 돌입한 듯. 3명 (3명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 11/04/10 08:58
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| hi***: 가디너반이 개개 파트에서 듣는재미를 풍부히 제공했다면, 스페링반은(실제연주는 어땠는지 모르겠지만) 홀 전체울림 중심으로 녹음되어 듣는 재미가 많지 않다. 목관파트가 유독 약해 9번특유의 녹아내릴 대목들에선 김이샌다.연주시간은 가디너와 비슷하고, 매케라스보다 1분짧지만 템포설정에 설득력이 떨어져서 듣는내내 속도에만 온신경이 집중된다. 너무 뭉텅뭉텅 끊어내는 느낌이 들어, 개인적으론 적응이 힘들었던 연주. 1명 (2명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 11/03/14 14:25
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
|
|
네티즌 리뷰 | | 리뷰는 동호회 게시판으로 링크됩니다.
BEETHOVEN: Symphony No. 9 in D minor op. 125 "Choral" | 등록된 음반: 330종 |
베토벤: 교향곡 9번 D단조 op. 125 "합창" (전곡녹음 - 녹음연도순) | 1929 | Oskar Fried |
| 1934/04/30 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1935/02/02-04 | Felix Weingartner [2] |
| 1936/03/08 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1937/05/01 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1937/11/03 | Arturo Toscanini [1] |
| 1938/02/06 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1939/12/02 | Arturo Toscanini [1] |
| 1940/05/02 | Willem Mengelberg [1] |
| 1941/07/24 | Arturo Toscanini [2] |
| 1941/09 | Karl Bohm |
| 1942/03/22 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [15] |
| 1942/04/19 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [2] |
| 1943/04/07 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1943/12/08 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1945/05/20,21 & 1946/01/12 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1946/06/24 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1947/11/03-05 & 12/10, 12, 14 | Herbert von Karajan
|
| 1947/11/13 | Bruno Walter [1] |
| 1948/04/03 | Arturo Toscanini [1] |
| 1949/04/05-1953/06/03(IV) | Bruno Walter |
| 1949/04/18, 05/04 | Bruno Walter |
| 1949/07/26 | Victor De Sabata |
| 1950/05/25 | Serge Koussevitzky |
| 1950/06/11 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1950/07/26 | Sergei Koussevitzky |
| 1950/09/07 | Fritz Busch |
| 1951/01/07 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1951/06/09 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1951/06/29 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1951/07/29 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [41] |
| 1951/08/31 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1951/12/20-22 | Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt |
| 1951/2/1 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1952/01/18 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1952/02/03 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [3] |
| 1952/03/31, 04/01 | Arturo Toscanini [2] |
| 1952/05/03-04 | Willem van Otterloo |
| 1952/11/24-26, 29, 12/01-02 | Eugen Jochum [3] |
| 1952/6 | Erich Kleiber [1] |
| 1953/01/06 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1953/05/30 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [5] |
| 1953/05/31 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1953/09 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1954/08/08 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1954/08/22 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [23] |
| 1954/09/12 | Carl Schuricht [1] |
| 1954/09/30 | Karl Bohm [2] |
| 1954/12/04 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1955/01/30 | Nikolai Malko |
| 1955/06/25 | Herbert von Karajan [2] |
| 1955/07/24 | Herbert von Karajan [2] |
| 1955/10/10 | Gunter Wand |
| 1955/11/13 | Bruno Walter |
| 1956/02 | Jascha Horenstein |
| 1956/05/17 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1956/08/19 | Sir Thomas Beecham [1] |
| 1957/04/25 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1957/06 | Karl Bohm [4] |
| 1957/10&12 | Otto Klemperer [1] |
| 1957/11/12 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1957/11/15 | Otto Klemperer
[4] |
| 1957/12 (p) 1958 | Andre Cluytens |
| 1957/12/28, 1958/01/02 & 1958/04/28-29 | Ferenc Fricsay [11] |
| 1958/01/06 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1958/03/28 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1958/04/25 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1958/05/27-29, 31 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1958/08/10 | Charles Munch |
| 1958/11/06 or 08 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1958/11/22 | Herbert von Karajan [2] |
| 1958/12/21, 22 | Charles Munch [7] |
| 1959 | Bruno Walter
[2] |
| 1959 | Franz Konwitschny |
| 1959/02/26 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1959/04 | Ernest Ansermet [4] |
| 1959/11/12 | Karl Bohm |
| 1960 | Otto Klemperer [1] |
| 1960 | Josef Krips |
| 1960/04/26 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1961/01 | Igor Markevitch [2] |
| 1961/04/21. 22 | George Szell [2] |
| 1961/05/01 | Franz Konwitschny |
| 1961/05/1~2 | Fritz Reiner [1] |
| 1961/06/03, 05, 07 | Rene Leibowitz [3] |
| 1961/09/13 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1961/11/27 | Otto Klemperer [1] |
| 1962/04/13 | Dean Dixon |
| 1962/06 | Pierre Monteux [3] |
| 1962/10-11 | Herbert von Karajan [20] |
| 1962/12/12 | Lovro von Matacic |
| 1962/12/27 | Charles Munch |
| 1963/06/28 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1963/07/23 | Karl Bohm [2] |
| 1963/10/15 | Herbert von Karajan [5] |
| 1963/10/31 | Yascha Horenstein |
| 1963/10/31 | Jascha Horenstein |
| 1963/11/07 | Karl Bohm [2] |
| 1964-66 | William Steinberg |
| 1964/05/18 | Leonard Bernstein [1] |
| 1964/07/09 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1964/09/05~29 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1964/11/8 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1965/04/05 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1965/05/05 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1965/06/15 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1965/06/23~28 | Paul Kletzki |
| 1965/08/28 | Josef Krips |
| 1965/12/08-12 | Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt [2] |
| 1965/12/25 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1966/04/16 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1966/11/08 | Paul Paray |
| 1966/12/29 | Lovro Von Matacic |
| 1967/09 | Leopold Stokowski [1] |
| 1968/01 & 02 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1968/11/12 | George Szell [9] |
| 1969/04/21~22 | Erich Leinsdorf [3] |
| 1969/06 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1970/04/25-30 | Karl Bohm [9] |
| 1970/05/05 | Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt [1] |
| 1970/05/06 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1970/06/30 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1970/12/25 | Jean Martinon |
| 1970/12/31 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1972/05 | Georg Solti [1] |
| 1972/11 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1973/05/31-06/04 | Rudolf Kempe [1] |
| 1973/12/19 | Lovro Von Matacic |
| 1973/12/31 | Arvid Jansons |
| 1974 | Janos Ferencsik |
| 1974/01 | Kurt Masur |
| 1974/01/14 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1974/02 | Seiji Ozawa |
| 1975/01 | Rafael Kubelik [3] |
| 1975/07/22-24 | Antal Dorati |
| 1976 | Yuri Simonov |
| 1976/05/14-17 | Bernard Haitink |
| 1976/09 | Herbert von Karajan [18] |
| 1976/12/03 | Vaclav Neumann |
| 1977/11/18 | Herbert von Karajan [4] |
| 1977/12/31 | Herbert von Karajan [8] |
| 1978/02/28-29 | Eugen Jochum [1] |
| 1978/09/18 | Erich Leinsdorf |
| 1978/10/13-15 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1979/04, 1980/03 | Herbert Blomstedt [8] |
| 1979/09 | Leonard Bernstein [8] |
| 1979/10/21 | Herbert von Karajan [4] |
| 1980/10 | Bernard Haitink |
| 1980/11 | Karl Bohm
[10] |
| 1981/01 | Kurt Sanderling [1] |
| 1981/10/08 | Kurt Masur [1] |
| 1982/05/14 | Rafael Kubelik [4] |
| 1982/06/12-19 | Otmar Suitner
|
| 1982/06/12-19 | Otmar Suitner |
| 1983 | Herbert Kegel |
| 1983/02/02 | Zubin Mehta [2] |
| 1983/05/15, 09/09,10 & 1984/11/25 | Michael Tilson Thomas |
| 1983/09 | Herbert von Karajan [13] |
| 1983/12/21 | Kazuo Yamada |
| 1985/03/30, 31 | Herbert Blomstedt [2] |
| 1985/04/28 | Antal Dorati |
| 1985/07 | Sir Colin Davis |
| 1985/10/18&19 | Christoph von Dohnanyi |
| 1985/9/13 | Klaus Tennstedt [4] |
| 1986/04/25 | Takashi Asahina [1] |
| 1986/05 | Claudio Abbado [5] |
| 1986/05/14-16 | Gunter Wand [5] |
| 1986/07 | Michael Gielen |
| 1986/09 | Georg Solti [7] |
| 1986/09/21-28 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1987/02 | Roger Norrington [3] |
| 1987/07/31 | Herbert Kegel |
| 1987/10/23 | Kurt Sanderling |
| 1987/12 | Bernard Haitink [2] |
| 1988/04 | Roy Goodman |
| 1988/05 | Richard Hickox |
| 1988/09 | Christopher Hogwood [2] |
| 1988/09 | Richard Edlinger |
| 1988/09/03~04 | Walter Weller |
| 1988/12/14 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1988/12/15 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1988/4 | Riccardo Muti [1] |
| 1989 | Eliahu Inbal |
| 1989/03/17 | Sergiu Celibidache [10] |
| 1989/03/19 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1989/07/03~04 | Andre Previn [1] |
| 1989/12/14 | Vaclav Neumann
Lubomir Matl(chorus master) |
| 1989/12/24 | Leonard Bernstein [16] |
| 1989/12/28 | Carl Auguste Bünte |
| 1989/12/30-1990/01/01 | Eliahu Inbal |
| 1989/2, 1990/2 | Carlo Maria Giulini [7] |
| 1989/4 | Neville Marriner |
| 1990 | Y. Simonov |
| 1990/1 & 1991/5 | Kurt Masur |
| 1990/12/21 | Peter Maag |
| 1991 | Kurt Masur |
| 1991/01/26~27 | Gerhard Samuel |
| 1991/03/3~5 | Sir Charles Mackerras [1] |
| 1991/06 & 12 | Peter Tiboris |
| 1991/06/21 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt [4] |
| 1991/07 | Alain Lombard |
| 1991/08/31 | Klaus Tennstedt [1] |
| 1992/10/08 | Klaus Tennstedt [3] |
| 1992/11/08-11 | Frans Bruggen [2] |
| 1992/12 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1992/12 | John Eliot Gardiner [16] |
| 1992/12/27-30 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 1993/07 | Sir Colin Davis [1] |
| 1994 | Raymond Leppard |
| 1994/05/15-31 | Kazimierz Kord |
| 1994/06/09, 11 | Jeffrey Thomas |
| 1994/08/26 | Sir Charles Mackerras |
| 1994/09 | Michael Gielen [2] |
| 1994/12/20 | Peter Maag |
| 1995/12/22 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1995/12/24 | Jean Fournet |
| 1996/03/24 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1996/04 | Giuseppe Sinopoli [2] |
| 1996/04/02-06 | Claudio Abbado [5] |
| 1996/8 | Bela Drahos [1] |
| 1997/07/06 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1998/06/04 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1998/10 | Philippe Herreweghe [2] |
| 1998/12/12&14 | David Zinman [3] |
| 1998/12/21-22 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 1998/5 | Masaaki Suzuki |
| 1999/05-06 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 1999/07 | Michael Gielen |
| 2000/04 | Claudio Abbado [22] |
| 2000/05/01 | Claudio Abbado [3] |
| 2000/05/16 | Rico Saccani |
| 2000/12/29~30 | Takashi Asahina |
| 2001 | Seiji Ozawa |
| 2001/12/29 | Taijiro Iimori |
| 2002/06~2003/03 | Jaap van Zweden |
| 2002/08/09 | Roger Norrington [2] |
| 2002/09 | Seiji Ozawa |
| 2002/4/29~2002/5/17 | Simon Rattle [4] |
| 2003/01/25, 26 | Donald Runnicles |
| 2004/12/23 | Myung-Whun Chung [3] |
| 2005/05/23-26 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski [1] |
| 2005/06/16~17 | Hugh Wolff |
| 2005/12-2006/05 | Gustav Kuhn |
| 2005/12/15 & 17-18 | Vladimir Ashkenazy [1] |
| 2006/01 | Osmo Vanska [4] |
| 2006/04 | Bernard Haitink [6] |
| 2006/05/30 | Georges Pretre |
| 2006/06/25~07/05 | Mikhail Pletnev [2] |
| 2006/07/28 | Christian Arming |
| 2006/08 & 09 | Sir Charles Mackerras [1] |
| 2006/08/27 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2006/09/06-08 | Hyunsuk Suh [1] |
| 2006/09/29, 10/01 | Kristjan Järvi |
| 2006/12/25 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2006/12/26 | James DePreist |
| 2006/12/31 | Jun Markl |
| 2007/01 | Franz Welser-Most [5] |
| 2007/04/17,18,20 | Jos van Immerseel [1] |
| 2007/06/17 | Christoph Spering [2] |
| 2007/07 | John Nelson |
| 2007/07/28, 30 | Paul Kim, Matthew Kim (Pf.) |
| 2007/10/20 | François-Xavier Roth [1] |
| 2007/10/27 | Mariss Jansons [1] |
| 2008/08/22~26 | Paavo Jarvi |
| 2008/08/23 | Lorin Maazel |
| 2008/12/27-31 | Riccardo Chailly [3] |
| 2009/06/02,03,05,06 | Emmanuel Krivine [1] |
| 2009/07/21~24 | Jean-Philippe Tremblay |
| 2009/10 | Philippe Herreweghe |
| 2010 | Jan Willem de Vriend |
| 2010/04 | Christian Thielemann [2] |
| 2010/05~2011/07 | Taijiro Iimori |
| 2010/12/23 | Dan Ettinger |
| 2011/01 | Douglas Boyd |
| 2011/08/23-28 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2011/09-12 | Tadaaki Otaka |
| 2011/09/07,09,10 | Kent Nagano |
| 2011/10/16 | Frans Bruggen |
| 2012/06/27-30 | Michael Tilson Thomas [1] |
| 2012/07/27 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2012/12/01 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2012/12/22-23 | Sylvain Cambreling |
| 2012/12/28 | Myung-Whun Chung [5] |
| 2013/01/09~11 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 2013/05/30-06/01 | Rafael Fruhbeck de Burgos |
| 2013/06/28 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2013/10/01 | Rudolf Lutz |
| 2014/02/20-21 | Ivan Fischer |
| 2014/11/08,09 | Zubin Mehta |
| 2014/11/09 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2015/07/04 | Koho Uno |
| 2015/09/26-27 | Martin Haselbock [1] |
| 2015/10/10&16 | Simon Rattle [1] |
| 2015/10/16 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2015/12/17~19 | Stefan Blunier |
| 2015/12/20 | Andrea Battistoni [1] |
| 2015/12/31 | Herbert Blomstedt [1] |
| 2016/02/4-7 | Bruno Weil
|
| 2016/06/04,05 | Peter Stangel [1] |
| 2016/09/05-07 | Giovanni Antonini |
| 2017.10.10-15 | Seiji Ozawa |
| 2017/05/21-22 | Philippe Jordan |
| 2018/02/26~03/03 | Jukka-Pekka Saraste |
| 2018/05/08~13 | Andris Nelsons [4] |
| 2018/06/07 | Michael Sanderling |
| 2018/07/12 | Jun-ichi Hirokami |
| 2018/07/16 | Joe Hisaishi |
| 2018/11/26-29 | Adam Fischer [1] |
| 2019/01 | Masaaki Suzuki
[3] |
| 2019/02/20-23 | Bernard Haitink |
| 2019/05/20~25 | Marek Janowski |
| 2019/06/06-09 | Manfred Honeck [8] |
| 2019/08/23 | Kirill Petrenko [1] |
| 2019/09/30 | Christoph Konig |
| 2019/10 | Robert Trevino [1] |
| 2019/11 | Pablo Heras-Casado |
| 2019/12 | Fabio Luisi |
| 2019/12/28-29 | Jonathan Nott |
| 2021/07/02~10 | Yannick Nezet-Seguin |
| 2021/09/30-10/01 | Jordi Savall |
| 2022/09/09 | Zubin Mehta |
|
재킷 사진은 외부 링크된 것이라 늦게 뜨거나 보이지 않을 수도 있습니다.
|