네티즌 200자평 | |
ma***: 샤이의 밸런스 감각은 이 곡에서도 빛을 발한다. 각 성부가 황금비라는 표현이 아깝지 않을 정도로 이상적인 균형을 이룬다. 특정 악구나 성부를 강조하는 일이 결코 없기 때문에 처음에는 상당히 밋밋하게 들릴 수도 있다. 그러나 듣다 보면 이것이 단점이 아니라는 사실을 깨닫게 될 것이다. 관현악의 음색이 투명하며 유려하게 해석된 2악장은 특히 탁월하다. 녹음도 우수하다. 순음악적인 해석을 원한다면 반드시 들어보시길. 4명 (7명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 07/08/05 22:57
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
|
|
네티즌 리뷰 | | 리뷰는 동호회 게시판으로 링크됩니다.
BRAHMS: Symphony No. 3 in F major op. 90 | 등록된 음반: 258종 |
브람스: 교향곡 3번 F장조 op. 90 (전곡녹음 - 녹음연도순) | 1928/09/25,26 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1930/01/16-20 | Clemens Krauss |
| 1931/05/10 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1932/05/10 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1936/05/18,19 | Bruno Walter |
| 1938/10/06 | Felix Weingartner |
| 1939 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1940/11/23 | Frederick Stock |
| 1941/02/08 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1942 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1942/12/20 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1944/02/27 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1944/09/09 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1946/03/20 & 22-23 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1946/03/31 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1946/04/19 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1946/10/08 | Serge Koussevitzky |
| 1948/4/19 | Karl Eliasberg |
| 1949/12/18 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1950 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1950 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1951/06/15 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1951/09/03 | George Szell [1] |
| 1951/12/15 | Guido Cantelli |
| 1952/02/01 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1952/04/20 | Dimitri Mitropoulos |
| 1952/05/21&22 | Sir John Barbirolli |
| 1952/10/01 | Arturo Toscanini [1] |
| 1952/11/04 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1952/3/17 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1953/06 | Karl Bohm [1] |
| 1953/08/26 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1953/12/21 & 23 | Bruno Walter |
| 1954/04/27 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1954/05/14 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1954/12/02 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1955/05/04 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1955/07/26 | Hans Knappertsbusch [3] |
| 1955/08/8,9,12,16 & 18 | Guido Cantelli |
| 1955/10/27 | Antal Dorati |
| 1956/03/08 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1956/04 | Eugen Jochum [2] |
| 1956/04/06 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1956/04/15 | Hermann Abendroth [1] |
| 1956/04/20 | Hans Rosbaud |
| 1956/08/29 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1956/09/24-25 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1956/11/04 | Hans Knappertsbusch [1] |
| 1957 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1957/03/26, 27 | Otto Klemperer [3] |
| 1957/12/12 | Antal Dorati |
| 1957/12/14 | Fritz Reiner [1] |
| 1958 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1958 | Jascha Horenstein |
| 1958/8/10 | Dimitri Mitropoulos |
| 1959 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1959/01/09~11 | Lorin Maazel [1] |
| 1960/01/19-23 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1960/01/27,30 | Bruno Walter [3] |
| 1960/05/03 | Paul Kletzki |
| 1960/09 | Herbert von Karajan [2] |
| 1960/11/30 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1961/01 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1961/06/28 | Paul Kletzki |
| 1961/9 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1962 | Witold Rowicki |
| 1962/04/25 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1962/05 | William Steinberg |
| 1962/05/14 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1962/09/05 | Hans Rosbaud |
| 1962/10/28 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1962/11/12 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1962/11/21 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1963 | Joseph Keilberth [1] |
| 1963/02 | Ernest Ansermet |
| 1963/05/19 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1963/08/21 | Karl Böhm |
| 1963/11/15 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1964/01/24 | Ernest Ansermet |
| 1964/04/17 | Leonard Bernstein [1] |
| 1964/05/12 | Paul Paray |
| 1964/09/28-30 | Herbert von Karajan [3] |
| 1964/10/16,17 | George Szell [2] |
| 1966/04/22 | Neeme Jarvi |
| 1967/01/31 & 03/13 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1967/12 | Sir John Barbirolli |
| 1969/02/04-05 | Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt |
| 1970/05 | Bernard Haitink [1] |
| 1970/08/19 | Ogan Durjan'Narc |
| 1970/10/27 | Karel Ancerl |
| 1970s | Hans Swarowsky |
| 1971 | Sir Adrian Boult |
| 1971/09/26 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1971/11/30 | Yevgeny Mravinsky |
| 1972 | Evgeny Mravinsky |
| 1972/01/10-13 | Kurt Sanderling [1] |
| 1972/01/26 | Evgeny Mravinsky |
| 1972/01/27 | Yevgeny Mravinsky [1] |
| 1972/04/19 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1972/06 | Claudio Abbado |
| 1973/01, 02, 05 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1973/02/27-28 | Istvan Kertesz [1] |
| 1973/08/01-03 | Leonard Bernstein [1] |
| 1973/12/05 | Lovro von Matacic |
| 1974/02/15 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1975/04/17 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1975/06 | Karl Bohm [1] |
| 1975/07 | James Loughran |
| 1976 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1976/02 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1976/05/17-24 | Maurice de Abravanel |
| 1976/07/12 | James Levine |
| 1976/09 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1976/10 | Kurt Masur |
| 1976/11/19 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1976ⓟ | Kirill Kondrashin |
| 1977/08/06 | Sir Adrian Boult |
| 1977/10-1978/02 | Herbert von karajan [2] |
| 1978/01/29 | Heinz Rögner |
| 1978/05 | Georg Solti |
| 1978/11/24 | Leonard Bernstein |
| 1979/06/20 | Sergiu Celibidache [2] |
| 1980/09/06 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1981/02 | Leonard Bernstein
[4] |
| 1981/09/30 | Zubin Metha |
| 1982 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1983/03 | Gunter Wand [1] |
| 1983/04/07 | Klaus Tennstedt |
| 1983/04/26-29 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1983/9/16-21 | Gunter Wand |
| 1985 | Otmar Suitner |
| 1986 | Marek Janowski |
| 1987/11/25,26 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 1988/05 | Christoph von Dohnanyi |
| 1988/07/11 | Neeme Jarvi |
| 1988/10 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1988/12/14~16 | Colin Davis |
| 1989/04 | Riccardo Muti |
| 1989/08/15 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1989/09 | Claudio Abbado [2] |
| 1989/09/07, 27, 30 | Jiří Bělohlávek |
| 1989/11/16 | Otmar Suitner |
| 1990 | Kurt Sanderling [1] |
| 1990/02/14 | Günter Wand |
| 1990/03/21 | Georg Tintner |
| 1990/05 | Carlo Maria Giulini [2] |
| 1990/05/01 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1990/06 | Alexander Rahbari |
| 1990/06/01 | Gary Bertini |
| 1990/07/10 | Francesco D'Avalos |
| 1991 | Christoph Eschenbach |
| 1991/03/24 | Vladimir Ashkenazy |
| 1991/09 | Seiji Ozawa |
| 1991/12 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1991/12 | Riccardo Chailly [1] |
| 1992/06/13 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1992/09 | Tove Lonskov(piano)
Rodolfo |
| 1992/10/02 | Emmanuel Krivine |
| 1992/10/04-27 | Zubin Mehta |
| 1992/10/22 | Sir Colin Davis |
| 1992/10/26~31 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 1992/11 | James Levine [1] |
| 1993/01/28 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1993/03 | Bernard Haitink |
| 1993/03/04,05 | Michael Gielen |
| 1993/05 | Kurt Masur |
| 1993/10/04-06 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 1995 | Idil Biret (Pf.) |
| 1995, 1997 | Idil Biret (Pf.) |
| 1995/03/12 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1995/04/09-11 | Gunter Wand |
| 1995/05 | Roger Norrington |
| 1995/10/10-13 | Cristian Mandeal |
| 1996/01/20 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt |
| 1996/04/15-20 | Silke-Thora Matthies
Christian |
| 1996/09/01-10 | Thomas Sanderling |
| 1997/01/06-30 | Sir Charles Mackerras |
| 1997/04 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt [1] |
| 1997/04/18 | Rafael Frübeck de Burgos |
| 1997/09 | Horst Stein |
| 1997/10/4 | Kurt Sanderling |
| 1998/02/09, 11, 13 | Lorin Maazel |
| 1998/03/10 | Tamas Vasary |
| 1999/4/16 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2000/05/11-14 | Paavo Berglund |
| 2001/02/26 | Takashi Asahina |
| 2001/03/14~15 | Gerd Albrecht |
| 2001/06/20-22 | Daniel Harding [1] |
| 2002 ⓟ | Erich Bergel |
| 2002/05/13-17 | Semyon Bychkov [1] |
| 2002/6-8/ | Jaap van Zweden [2] |
| 2003/06/22 | Gary Bertini |
| 2004/06/16-17 | Bernard Haitink |
| 2005 | William Eddins |
| 2005/02/21~24 | Martin Sieghart |
| 2005/03 | Marin Alsop [2] |
| 2005/06/06~08, 2006/05/23~26 | Owain Arwel Hughes |
| 2005/07/04-06 | Roger Norrington |
| 2005/2/7 | Yuri Bashmet |
| 2007/03 | Marek Janowski |
| 2007/04/12~13, 16~17 | Gustav Kuhn |
| 2007/11/16, 2008/10/04~05, 08 | Sir John Eliot Gardiner [2] |
| 2008/08/29 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2008/09/10 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 2008/10/27 | Georges Pretre |
| 2008/10/29~11/14 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2008/11/14 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2009-2010 | Andrew Manze |
| 2009/04/03 | Daniel Raiskin |
| 2009/10/08-10 | Simone Young |
| 2009/10/13, 14, 16 | Zubin Mehta |
| 2009/10/22 | Christoph von Dohnanyi |
| 2010/01/16 | Mariss Jansons [1] |
| 2010/03/29-30 | Taijiro Iimori |
| 2010/04 | David Zinman |
| 2010/10/27 | Vladimir Jurowski |
| 2010/12/02-03 | Zdenek Macal |
| 2011/03/10-13 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 2011/10/02 | Jun Markl |
| 2011/10/05~07 | Alan Gilbert |
| 2011/12/10~12 | Marcus Bosch |
| 2012/10 | Riccardo Chailly |
| 2012/10/22 | Christian Thielemann [1] |
| 2012/12/11, 18 | Valery Gergiev |
| 2013/01/23~27 | Jukka-Pekka Saraste |
| 2013/05/13-17 | Andres Orozco-Estrada |
| 2013/10/11-12 | Radomil Eliska |
| 2013/12 | Christian Thielemann |
| 2014/02/22 | SIR SIMON RATTLE |
| 2014/04/17~19 | Norichika Iimori |
| 2014/08/27~28 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 2014/09/25 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2015/09 | Mario Venzago |
| 2015/09/15 | Franz Welser-Most |
| 2016/05/22 | Thomas Hengelbrock |
| 2016/11 | Andris Nelsons |
| 2016/11 | Thomas Dausgaard |
| 2016/11/16-19 | Thomas Hengelbrock |
| 2016/12/19-22 | Paavo Jarvi |
| 2017/05/15-29 | Robin Ticciati |
| 2017/06/18-21 | Kalman Berkes |
| 2017/10 | Daniel Barenboim [1] |
| 2018/04/04 | Paavo Jarvi |
| 2018/10/02-05 | Edward Gardner |
| 2019/09/04 | Tadaaki Otaka |
| 2019/09/28-29 | Philippe Jordan |
| 2020/02/27-29 | Christoph Eschenbach |
| 2020/04/14~18 | Notos Quartett |
| 2020/08/30-09/02 | Ivan Fischer |
| 2021/01/26~29, 02/02~05 | Nicholas Milton |
| 2021/04 | Herbert Blomstedt [1] |
| 2021/05/10-18, 07/03-06, 09/23-25 & 2022/02/12-14 | Adam Fischer |
| 2021/07/09 | Michiyoshi Inoue |
| 2022/02/09 | Joe Hisaishi |
| 2022/10/12-14 | Michael Sanderling |
|
재킷 사진은 외부 링크된 것이라 늦게 뜨거나 보이지 않을 수도 있습니다.
|