네티즌 200자평 (가장 최근 것이 위에) | |
nk***: 정말 완성도가 높은 연주입니다. 모든 파트가 맞물려 돌아가는것이 눈에 훤히 보입니다. 아마 실황으로 들었으면 매우 감탄했을지도 모르겠습니다. 과거 헤비급연주에서 찾을 수 있었던 진중하고 무거운 맛, 근엄한 영웅을 원하신다면 강력한 비추입니다만 이런 해석도 좋습니다. 5명 (6명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 13/03/20 09:16
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| ne***: 소리가 좋다기보다는 '정밀하게 잘 들린다' 하지만 정말 감동을 주는 소리인지 생각해봐야할듯. 무엇보다 템포가 적응이 안된다. 에로이카가 이런 곡인지. 다른 시각에서의 해석을 제공하는 것도 중요하겠지만 나는 이 연주에 감동받을 수 없다. 시간이 지나고나서 이 연주가 어떤 평가를 받게될지 정말 궁금하다. 10명 (16명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 11/12/30 21:29
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| ro***: 이런 베토벤을 기다려왔다. 2006년에 발표됐던 파보예르비,도이치캄머필 연주와 비교해서 들으면 더 재미있다. 휘몰아치는 감정에 빠지지 않고 순수한 음악자체에 몰입할 수 있다. 강추! 10명 (13명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 11/12/16 09:05
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
| si***: 단순히 악보의 재현이 아니라 지휘자가 얼마나 작품에 대하여 고심을 했는가가 전곡 구석구석에 반영되어 있다. 명연을 넘어선 문제작이다...후배 지휘자들을 고민하게 만드는 하나의 레퍼런스가 제시되어 있다. 10명 (14명의 회원님 중)이 위의 글이 도움이 된다고 하셨습니다. | 11/12/13 10:43
도움이 되셨습니까? [예] [아니오] |
|
|
네티즌 리뷰 | | 리뷰는 동호회 게시판으로 링크됩니다.
BEETHOVEN: Symphony No. 3 in E flat major op. 55 "Eroica" | 등록된 음반: 377종 |
베토벤: 교향곡 3번 E flat장조 op. 55 "영웅" (전곡녹음 - 녹음연도순) | 1924 | Oskar Fried |
| 1929 | Hans Pfitzner |
| 1930/01/04-09 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1935 | Felix Weingartner |
| 1936/05/22-23 | Felix Weingartner |
| 1938/12/03 | Arturo Toscanini [1] |
| 1939/10/28 | Arturo Toscanini [2] |
| 1940/04 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1940/04/14 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1940/11/11 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1941 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1941/01/20 | Bruno Walter |
| 1941/09 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1942/03/05 | Willem Mengelberg |
| 1943 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1943 | Oswald Kabasta |
| 1943/06/19 | Oswald Kabasta |
| 1944/05 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1944/12/19-20 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [2] |
| 1945/09/01 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1946/05/2-3 | Victor de Sabata [1] |
| 1947/11/10-12 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1948/01/10 | Erich Kleiber |
| 1949/01/24 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1949/03/21, 04/16, 05/05 | Bruno Walter |
| 1949/11/28 & 12/05 | Arturo Toscanini |
| 1949/12/11 | Dimitri Mitropoulos [3] |
| 1950/04/27 | King Frederik IX [1] |
| 1950/05/08 | Erich Kleiber |
| 1950/06/20 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1950/08/31 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1950s | Ataulfo Argenta |
| 1951/01 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1951/05/09 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1951/05/26-28 | Paul van Kempen [1] |
| 1952/03/12 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1952/1/19 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1952/11 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1952/11/26, 27 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [3] |
| 1952/11/30 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [2] |
| 1952/12/07 | Wilhelm Furtwangler |
| 1952/12/08 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [6] |
| 1952/2/29 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1953 | Jascha Horenstein [1] |
| 1953/04/11 | Erich Kleiber [2] |
| 1953/06/22 | Leonard Bernstein |
| 1953/08/26 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [1] |
| 1953/09/04 | Wilhelm Furtwangler [3] |
| 1953/09/08 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1953/09/22 | Hermann Abendroth |
| 1953/12/06 | Arturo Toscanini [2] |
| 1953/12/17 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1954/02/01-05, 07 | Eugen Jochum |
| 1954/02/08 | Otto Klemperer [1] |
| 1954/02/13 | Hermann Abendroth [3] |
| 1954/12/04 | Fritz Reiner |
| 1955 | Franz Konwitschny [1] |
| 1955/02/05 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1955/04 | Clemens Krauss |
| 1955/07/07 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1955/10/03, 04 & 12/07 | Otto Klemperer [7] |
| 1955/10/10 | Dimitri Mitropoulos [1] |
| 1955/10/30 | William Steinberg |
| 1955/11/06 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1955/12/31 | Erich Kleiber |
| 1955/4 | Erich Kleiber [1] |
| 1956 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1956/02/29 | Rafael Kubelik [1] |
| 1956/06 | Sir Adrian Boult |
| 1956/09/21 | Charles Munch |
| 1956/12/19-21, 1957/01/30 | Igor Markevitch [2] |
| 1957 | Jascha Horenstein |
| 1957 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1957 | Jascha Horenstein |
| 1957/02/03 | Bruno Walter |
| 1957/02/22-23 | George Szell [2] |
| 1957/03/09 | Antal Dorati |
| 1957/04/26 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1957/05/05 | Eduard van Beinum |
| 1957/05/24 | Ataulfo Argenta |
| 1957/08/09 | George Szell |
| 1957/11/30 | Charles Munch |
| 1957/12/02 | Charles Munch |
| 1957/12/18,20,23 | Carl Schuricht [1] |
| 1958/03/29 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1958/04/17 | Otto Klemperer [1] |
| 1958/05 | Hermann Scherchen [5] |
| 1958/09/18 | Josef Krips |
| 1958/10/06-13 | Ferenc Fricsay [2] |
| 1958/12 | Andre Cluytens [4] |
| 1959/01/20-25 | Bruno Walter |
| 1959/03/15-18 | Lovro von Matacic [2] |
| 1959/06/02 | Sir Georg Solti |
| 1959/06/19~25 | Hans Rosbaud |
| 1959/10 & 11 | Otto Klemperer [6] |
| 1959/2 | Paul van Kempen |
| 1959/5 | Georg Solti [1] |
| 1959/9/03 | Rudolf Kempe [2] |
| 1960 | Josef Krips |
| 1960-1961 | Malcolm Sargent |
| 1960/03/01 | Franz Konwitschny |
| 1960/04 | Ernest Ansermet [2] |
| 1960/11/12 | Pierre Monteux |
| 1960/5/29 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1960/6/7 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1961/04/09 | Eugene Ormandy |
| 1961/04/10-12 | Rene Leibowitz [1] |
| 1961/06/02 | Evgeny Mravinsky |
| 1961/08/23 | Carl Schuricht [2] |
| 1961/12 | Karl Bohm [7] |
| 1961/2/5 | Ferenc Fricsay [1] |
| 1962 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1962/02/17 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1962/04 | Hans Knappertsbusch |
| 1962/06/10 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1962/07/01-03 | Pierre Monteux [3] |
| 1962/09/30 | Erich Leinsdorf |
| 1962/10/29 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1962/11 | Herbert Von Karajan [6] |
| 1962/11/19 | Lovro von Matacic |
| 1962/6/16 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1963/05/14 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1963/08/04 | George Szell [1] |
| 1964-66 | William Steinberg |
| 1964/01/27 | Leonard Bernstein |
| 1964/10/08 | Carl Schuricht |
| 1965/02/12 | Hermann Scherchen |
| 1965/02/20-28 | Gunter Wand |
| 1965/11 | Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt [1] |
| 1966 ⓟ | Michael Gielen |
| 1966/04/14 | Herbert von Karajan |
| 1967/02/18~21 | Paul Kletzki |
| 1967/02/21 | Jean Martinon |
| 1967/03/05-13 | Rafael Kubelik |
| 1967/05/11 | George Szell |
| 1967/05/18-19 | Sir John Barbirolli [5] |
| 1967/10/17 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1967/12/20-22 | Max Rudolf |
| 1968/01/30 | Sir Georg Solti |
| 1968/05/15 | Joseph Keilberth |
| 1968/10/31 | Evgeny Mravinsky |
| 1969/05/28-29 | Eugen Jochum [1] |
| 1970 | Sir John Barbirolli |
| 1970/01/28 | Jean Martinon |
| 1970/03/22 | Sergiu Celibidache |
| 1970/04/15 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1970/05/26 | Otto Klemperer |
| 1970/09 | Colin Davis |
| 1970/10/22,23 | Michael Gielen |
| 1971 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1971 | Sergiu Celibidache [1] |
| 1971 | Janos Ferencsik [1] |
| 1971/08/13 | Rafael Kubelik [1] |
| 1971/09/10-18 | Karl Bohm [4] |
| 1971/10 | Herbert von Karajan [3] |
| 1971/10/20, 21 | Rafael Kubelik [3] |
| 1972 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1972 | Rudolf Barshai |
| 1972/06/23-26 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1973/11 | Kurt Masur |
| 1973/11 | Sir Georg Solti [3] |
| 1974/03/25-27 | Leopold Stokowski |
| 1974/05/22 | Rudolf Kempe |
| 1974/11/18-21 | Bernard Haitink |
| 1975/05 | Seiji Ozawa [1] |
| 1975/09 | Carlos Paita [7] |
| 1975/09/02 | Herbert Kegel |
| 1976 | Franzjosef Maier: leader |
| 1976/05 | Herbert Blomstedt [4] |
| 1976/07/01-03 | Eugen Jochum [2] |
| 1976/09/24-25 | Antal Dorati |
| 1977/01 | Herbert von Karajan [9] |
| 1977/04/02 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1977/04/21 | Eugen Jochum [1] |
| 1977/10/28 | Hiroshi Wakasugi |
| 1977/11/13 | Herbert von Karajan [1] |
| 1977/3/22 | Otmar Suitner |
| 1978/02 | Leonard Bernstein [5] |
| 1978/11 | Carlo Maria Giulini [5] |
| 1978/11/04-05 | Leonard Bernstein |
| 1978/12/07-08 | Karl Bohm [2] |
| 1978? | Lorin Maazel |
| 1979/03/11 | Kirill Kondrashin |
| 1979/07/03-06 | Klaus Tennstedt [1] |
| 1979/10/03 | Klaus Tennstedt |
| 1980/03/31 | Zubin Mehta [1] |
| 1980/06/23-25 | Otmar Suitner [1] |
| 1980/10 | Michael Gielen |
| 1981 | Evgeny Svetlanov [1] |
| 1981/01-02 | Kurt Sanderling |
| 1982 | Gunther Herbig [1] |
| 1982/04/30 LIVE | Herbert von Karajan [10] |
| 1982/06 | Neville Marriner |
| 1982/08/29 | Klaus Tennstedt |
| 1983 | Herbert Kegel
|
| 1983/10 | Karl Munchinger |
| 1983/10/23 | Christoph von Dohnanyi |
| 1984/01 | Herbert Von Karajan [19] |
| 1985 | Gunter Wand |
| 1985/06 | Claudio Abbado |
| 1985/08 | Christopher Hogwood [1] |
| 1985/11/06 | Horst Stein |
| 1986 | Michael Tilson Thomas |
| 1986/02/28 | Woldemar Nelsson |
| 1987 | Jaap Schroder |
| 1987 | Jaap Schroder |
| 1987/01 | Riccardo Muti [3] |
| 1987/01/10 | Michael Gielen |
| 1987/04 | Bernard Haitink [1] |
| 1987/04/06-07 | Horst Stein |
| 1987/04/12-13 | Sergiu Celibidache [2] |
| 1987/10 | Roger Norrington |
| 1987/11 | Frans Bruggen [1] |
| 1987/11 | Frans Bruggen |
| 1987/11/23 | Roy Goodman [1] |
| 1988 | Michael Halasz |
| 1988/02/08-10 | Wyn Morris |
| 1988/03/02-06 | Michael Halasz |
| 1988/03/30 | Georg Tintner |
| 1988/05 | Richard Hickox |
| 1988/07/03, 09/05~06 | Walter Weller |
| 1988/09/16 | Evgeny Svetlanov |
| 1988/10/16 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt |
| 1989/02/05 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1989/08/31 | Gary Bertini |
| 1989/09/24 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1989/10 | Rafael Fruhbeck de Burgos |
| 1989/12 | Michael Gielen |
| 1989/12/10-12 | Gunter Wand |
| 1989/12/30 | Georg Solti [3] |
| 1990/02 | Alexander Rahbari |
| 1990/03/25 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1990/07/03 | Nikolaus Harnoncourt [1] |
| 1990/09/21,22 | Gunther Herbig |
| 1990/5 | Herbert Blomstedt |
| 1991/02 | Sir Colin Davis |
| 1991/07 | Alain Lombard |
| 1991/10/03 | Klaus Tennstedt [1] |
| 1992/06/21 | Riccardo Muti |
| 1992/10 | Kurt Masur |
| 1992/11/15-17 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1993/03 | John Eliot Gardiner [6] |
| 1993/06 | James Levine [3] |
| 1993/10/28 | Giuseppe Sinopoli |
| 1993/6 | Wolfgang Sawallisch |
| 1994 | Gunther Herbig |
| 1994/01 | Jordi Savall [3] |
| 1994/02/15 | Gunter Wand [3] |
| 1994/05/17 | Carlo Maria Giulini |
| 1994/06 | Gunther Herbig |
| 1994/06 | Sir Yehudi Menuhin |
| 1994/07/13-16 | Peter Maag |
| 1994/09 | Heinrich Schiff |
| 1994/09/9,10 | Sir Charles Mackerras |
| 1994/11/28 | Peter Tiboris |
| 1994/9/9~10 | Sir Charles Mackerras [1] |
| 1995/06/21-24 | Bela Drahos |
| 1996/09 | Kazimierz Kord |
| 1996/11/29 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1997/01 | Joseph Rescigno |
| 1997/02/16 | Tamás Vásáry [1] |
| 1997/04 | Seiji Ozawa |
| 1997/04/13 | Mariss Jansons |
| 1997/05/01 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 1997/09/25 | Takashi Asahina |
| 1997/11/13-15 | Hans Vonk |
| 1998/5 | David Zinman [2] |
| 1999 | Enoch zu Guttenberg |
| 1999/05-06 | Daniel Barenboim [2] |
| 1999/08/26-28 | Ancient Consort Praha |
| 1999/12/30 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2000/02 | Michael Gielen |
| 2000/03 | Claudio Abbado [3] |
| 2000/03/16 | Taijiro Iimori |
| 2000/04/24 | Horst Stein |
| 2000/07/08 | Takashi Asahina |
| 2000/07/23 | Takashi Asahina |
| 2001/02 | Claudio Abbado [1] |
| 2002 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 2002/04/29-05/17 | Simon Rattle [1] |
| 2002/05, 10 | Thomas Dausgaard [1] |
| 2002/06/10 | Myung-Whun Chung |
| 2002/06~2003/03 | Jaap van Zweden |
| 2002/08 | Roger Norrington [1] |
| 2003/04 | Helmut Muller-Bruhl |
| 2003/10 | Daniel Grossmann |
| 2003/10/08-10 | Hyunsuk Suh [1] |
| 2004/04/09 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 2004/10/03-04 | Lothar Zagrosek |
| 2004/11/19 | Hisayoshi Inoue |
| 2004/11/24 | Kurt Masur |
| 2004/11/27-30 | Myung-Whun Chung 정명훈 [1] |
| 2004/5/13-15 | Michael Tilson Thomas |
| 2005/01/15, 16 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski [2] |
| 2005/06. 2006/01 | Osmo Vanska [1] |
| 2005/08/27-29 | Paavo Jarvi |
| 2005/11 | Bernard Haitink [2] |
| 2005/11/19 | James DePreist |
| 2005/12-2006/05 | Gustav Kuhn |
| 2006 | Bertrand de Billy [1] |
| 2006/01 | John Nelson |
| 2006/05/09-12 | Giovanni Antonini [1] |
| 2006/05/1-4 | Jos van Immerseel |
| 2006/06/25~07/05 | Mikhail Pletnev [2] |
| 2006/08 & 09 | Sir Charles Mackerras |
| 2006/08/21~29 | Hugh Wolff |
| 2006/09/27~28 | Vladimir Ashkenazy [1] |
| 2007/06/26-29 | Philippe Herreweghe |
| 2007/09/12-13 | Georges Pretre |
| 2007/11/08, 11 | Yannick Nézet-Séguin |
| 2008/03 | John Neschling |
| 2008/08/19 | Lorin Maazel |
| 2008/09/30-10/04 | Riccardo Chailly [4] |
| 2008/10/26 | Christoph von Dohnányi |
| 2009/02/14 | Sylvain Cambreling |
| 2009/03 | Christian Thielemann [3] |
| 2009/04/04 | Eliahu Inbal [1] |
| 2009/06/12 | Masahiro Arita |
| 2009/07/21~24 | Jean-Philippe Tremblay |
| 2009/12/11-12,17-18 | Emmanuel Krivine [1] |
| 2010 | Jan Willem de Vriend |
| 2010/01 | Paul Kim (Pf.) |
| 2010/04/29~30 | Ken-Ichiro Kobayashi |
| 2010/05 | Kent Nagano [1] |
| 2010/11/11 | Taijiro Iimori |
| 2011/08/23-28 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2011/09-12 | Tadaaki Otaka |
| 2011/10 | Frans Brüggen [2] |
| 2011/10/21,22 | Hidemi Suzuki |
| 2012 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2012/03/08-15 | Gustavo Dudamel [2] |
| 2012/05/24-27 | Bruno Weil |
| 2012/07/13 | Dan Ettinger |
| 2012/07/21 | Daniel Barenboim |
| 2012/09/29 | Stanislaw Skrowaczewski |
| 2012/10/06 | Bernard Haitink |
| 2012/10/18-19 | Mariss Jansons [1] |
| 2012/12/06-07 | Rafael Fruhbeck de Burgos |
| 2013 | Zubin Mehta |
| 2013/05/31 | Ivan Fischer |
| 2013/08/16~17 | Claudio Abbado |
| 2014/01/22 | Vladimir Jurowski |
| 2014/01/23,07/02 | Peter Stangel |
| 2014/12 | Herbert Blomstedt [1] |
| 2015/01/17 | Christian Thielemann [3] |
| 2015/03/22~25 | Stefan Blunier |
| 2015/10/06&12 | Simon Rattle [3] |
| 2015/10/12 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2016/05/01 | Sir Simon Rattle |
| 2016/05/20-25 | Martin Haselbock |
| 2016/06/24~25 | Michael Sanderling |
| 2016/10/20 | Ivan Fischer |
| 2017/02/12 | Joe Hisaishi |
| 2017/02/25,26 | Philippe Jordan |
| 2017/09/20~23 | Maxim Emelyanychev |
| 2017/10/23-26 | Adam Fischer |
| 2017/10/27-29 | Manfred Honeck [3] |
| 2017/11/20~25 | Jukka-Pekka Saraste |
| 2018/02/05 | Christoph Konig |
| 2018/05/17 | Mariss Jansons |
| 2018/07 | Esa-Pekka Salonen |
| 2019/02/11~15 | Marek Janowski |
| 2019/03/23 | Remy Ballot |
| 2019/04/1~2 | Andris Nelsons [2] |
| 2019/09 | Arthur Schoonderwoerd |
| 2019/10 | Robert Trevino |
| 2019/10/05-09 | Jordi Savall [1] |
| 2020/03 & 09 | Francois-Xavier Roth |
| 2020/08/14-15 | Herbert Blomstedt |
| 2021/07/02~10 | Yannick Nezet-Seguin |
| 2021/10/15 | Zubin Mehta |
| 2023/08 | Ivan Fischer |
|
재킷 사진은 외부 링크된 것이라 늦게 뜨거나 보이지 않을 수도 있습니다.
|